So I decided, hey, let’s do a seal brown horse. Sounded like a decent way to spend a weekend, you know? Grabbed my gear, thought it’d be a straightforward job. Man, was I wrong.

The Color Problem
First thing that hit me was the color itself. Seal brown. It’s not just ‘dark brown.’ Oh no. It’s got this whole vibe. Sometimes it looks almost black, then the light hits it and you see these warm, rich tones, but not quite red, not quite chocolate. It’s a proper pain, to be honest.
I started mixing. If it was digital, I was fiddling with sliders for hours. If it was actual paint, well, let’s just say my palette looked like a mud wrestling pit after a week-long festival. I must’ve made fifty shades of ‘not quite seal brown.’ It was a real struggle to capture that specific look.
- Too dark, it just looked like a black blob, no life to it.
- Too red, and suddenly it’s a liver chestnut wannabe, not what I was going for.
- Too flat, it lost all the depth that makes seal brown interesting.
People would look over my shoulder. ‘Just use a standard dark brown,’ they’d say. Like, you think I didn’t try that? That’s like telling a baker to ‘just add sugar’ when the whole recipe is off. It doesn’t get the specific feel of a seal brown horse, you know? The way the light catches the coat, the subtle shifts in color. Standard dark brown is just… well, it’s just plain boring next to the real deal.
Down the Rabbit Hole
I got a bit obsessed, I won’t lie. Started looking at photos of actual seal brown horses, comparing them in different lights. Sun, shade, cloudy day. Each one looked a bit different! It was like the horse itself was playing tricks on me. Then I found myself reading about horse color genetics. Bay, black, the agouti locus… stuff I really didn’t need to know for this project but ended up reading anyway. A total sidetrack, all for a single color.
This whole thing reminded me of this one time I was trying to fix an old radio. Thought it was just a loose wire, you know, a quick fix. Ended up taking the entire thing apart, pieces spread out all over the workbench. And for what? To find out the main transformer was completely shot. Sometimes you jump in thinking it’s a small puddle and then you realize you’re in the middle of an ocean, and all you’ve got is your little bucket.

So, with this horse, after what felt like ages, I had all these test patches, these digital swatches, and honestly, none of them felt perfectly right. It was like I was building a patchwork quilt made entirely of my failures. You look at it and just think, ‘Why on earth did I even start this?’ I could’ve just done a simple bay horse. Or a gray one. Anything but this ridiculously picky seal brown.
Where I Landed
Eventually, I just had to pick one and move on. Was it the absolute perfect, one-hundred-percent accurate seal brown? Probably not. If you put my work next to a real seal brown horse, some expert would probably squint and say, ‘Hmm, pretty close, but…’ But you know what? Life’s too short to get hung up on perfection forever. I got it to a point where it looked good enough for me, and that had to be okay. Sometimes ‘good enough’ is the real ‘perfect,’ if you ask me.
I still keep some of those failed color swatches though. Pinned them up on my board. They’re a little reminder that sometimes the things that sound simplest can really drag you through the mud. And that ‘seal brown’ is a deceptively tricky customer. Every time I glance at them, I just gotta shake my head and chuckle a bit. What a ride for a horse color, eh?